About this lesson

A closer look

In 2015, a study led by former NASA scientist James Hansen argued that Greenland and Antarctica could melt fast enough to raise sea levels by several meters this century. Climate scientist Kevin Trenberth found the study provocative and intriguing but built on too many assumptions. This lesson uses their disagreement to explore how scientists evaluate bold claims, models, and evidence.

Suggested grade level

Grades 9–12

Suggested teaching range based on the reading, scientific concepts, and classroom activity. Teachers can adapt the lesson for their students.

Source material

This curriculum draws on material from theconversation.com.

Read the original source (opens in a new tab)

Read the curriculum

Open PDF in a new tab ↗

Preview not available on your device? Open the PDF above or download a copy.